According to Julie Powell, “The road to hell is paved with leeks and potatoes.”
In her self-described “chick lit” book, “Julie & Julia,” bad news from a doctor prompts her to create a comfort food, Potage Parmentier, emphasizing that “simple” ingredients do not equate to an “easy” dish.
That’s not how director-screenwriter Nora Ephron begins her reinvention of Julie Powell’s story in the film version. Her Julie is introduced to us as a despairing secretary, endlessly answering calls from New York’s 9/11 victims.
Two different beginnings for the introduction of Julie’s character, yet they still led to the same place: someone who finds consolation through cooking.
In linking the lives of Julie Powell and Julia Child, Ephron took a few liberties from the original stories, as do most screenwriters. Adapting two separate works for the same screen may warrant more deviations from the source materials than is usual. And to make things even more confusing, Powell changes things around from the original blog. That potato soup referenced earlier? In the blog, she made it on Friday, Aug. 30, not the day the blog was conceived which was Aug. 25. Little details? Yes. Does it matter? Probably not.
The bones of the stories are still there; the messages remain the same. The goodness of Julia Child’s movie persona could make most saints pale in comparison. Julie Powell is shown as more neurotic and less profane than she probably is in real life. Her girlfriends are probably not as one-dimensional as they were portrayed in the lunch scene — all ordering variations on the same Cobb salad. (Again, another scene that was not in either the book or blog.)
Ephron wants us to realize that comforting feeling that comes from the predictability of a recipe. Life’s path may seem arbitrary, but there are always things we can control, even if it is simply what’s for dinner.
So is Leek & Potato Soup the path to hell or a diversion to salvation? You decide.
Potage Parmentier
(Leek or Onion and Potato Soup)
Leek and potato soup smells good, tastes good, and is simplicity itself to make. It is also versatile as a soup base; add watercress and you have a watercress soup, or stir in cream and chill it for a vichyssoise. To change the formula a bit, add carrots, broccoli, or anything else you think would go with it, and vary the proportions as you wish.
For about 2 quarts serving 6 to 8 people.
A 3- to 4-quart saucepan or pressure cooker
3 to 4 cups or 1 pound peeled potatoes, sliced or diced
3 cups or 1 pound thinly sliced leeks including the tender green; or yellow onions
2 quarts of water
1 tablespoon salt
4 to 6 tablespoons whipping cream or 2 to 3 tablespoons butter
2 to 3 tablespoons minced parsley or chives
Mash the vegetables in the soup with a fork, or pass the soup through a food mill. Correct seasoning. Set aside uncovered until just before serving, then reheat to the simmer.
Take off heat and just before serving, stir in the cream or butter by spoonfuls. Pour into a tureen or soup cups and decorate with the herbs.
Adapted from “Mastering the Art of French Cooking” by Julia Chile, Louisette Bertholle and Simone Beck










